- Maple Retreat with Big PoolDundee7.5
- Schoenbrunn Inn8.4New Philadelphia
- TownePlace Suites by Marriott New PhiladelphiaNew Philadelphia8.5
- Secluded New Philadelphia Home in Amish Country!New Philadelphia7.0
- Spacious Ohio Family Home on 5-Acre Property!New Philadelphia
- Spark By Hilton Newcomerstown8.7Newcomerstown
- Quaint Winesburg Cottage with Porch and Pond!Dundee10.0
- Farmhouse of BlessingsDundee9.8
- Timeless Winesburg Farmhouse with DeckDundee10.0
- Quality Inn8.7Dover
- Morning MistSugarcreek9.8
- PIne Valley Guesthouse10.0
- Inn at Amish Door9.4Wilmot
- A Winfield BungalowDover9.0
- Downtown Escape Great for large families & groupsSugarcreek8.8
- Rustic Dundee Log Cabin with Hot Tub and Forest Views!Dundee9.4
- 1873 Victorian Rose B & BNewcomerstown9.7
- Hampton Inn New Philadelphia8.5New Philadelphia
- Best Western Dutch Valley Inn7.3New Philadelphia
- Dover Inn and Suites5.5Dover
- Carlisle Inn9.4Sugarcreek
- Comfort Inn & Suites8.9Dover
- Travelodge by Wyndham New Philadelphia7.0New Philadelphia
- Ramada by Wyndham Strasburg Dover8.1Strasburg
- Bolivar Getaway Near Pro Football Hall of Fame!Bolivar
- Sleep Inn8.5Bolivar
- Farmyard Stays Dundee Home Near HikingDundee10.0
- Red Roof Inn Uhrichsville6.8Uhrichsville
- Super 8 by Wyndham Newcomerstown7.2Newcomerstown
- Days Inn by Wyndham New Philadelphia4.0New Philadelphia
